The protection has of the right to one’s image undergone a deep evolution over the years, starting from the definition of the concept of “image”. Whilst the concept was originally referred to the reproduction of a person’s physical appearance through photography, cinematography and other forms of expression characteristic of the visual arts, it has subsequently been extended to include forms of representation that allow the subject to be identified regardless of the reproduction of their physical features (such, for example, the use of their distinctive accessories stylised likenesses or a lookalike).
The use of another person’s image is subject to the consent of the person depicted, who usually gives such consent expressly, with a release form or a contract. Only where the behaviour of the person depicted unequivocally shows the willingness to authorize the use of their image, the consent may be deemed ‘tacit’ or ‘implied’, that is, inferred from the behaviour itself.
The general principle that consent is required is subject to certain exceptions, for example where the reproduction of an image is justified by the public profile of the person depicted. In this case, the public’s right to information is considered to prevail over the famous person’s right to privacy
On this point, case law has clarified that the use of a famous person’s image is lawful not only when the person is depicted in the context of the activity that gave rise to their fame, but also where they are depicted carrying out ancillary activities, connected with the main activity that made them famous. However, consent remains necessary to reproduce images of a well-known person that haven’t any connection with the activity that led to their fame and that concern their personal life, because in these cases the disclosure serves no general public interest and only aims to satisfy simple curiosity.
Consent is, however, required when the well-known person’s image is used for promotional purposes, because in such cases there’s no peculiar informational purpose and the main objective is to take advantage of the depicted person’s fame to promote the product or service on the market.
Another exception to the principle requiring consent applies where the person depicted has taken part in an event of public interest or an event that took place in public.
Also in this case, the right to privacy of the person depicted is overridden by the prevailing right to information regarding events that took place in public which, although held in private settings, are of public interest, for example because of the participants.
In this regard, it should be noted that the public interest referred to in the law must be understood not as a mere curiosity, but as the public benefit of disclaiming the image. The use of another person’s image without any consent is, therefore, lawful only to the extent that it serves the need to inform the public about that event, that is, when knowledge of the event necessarily implies the knowledge of its participants.
Finally, consent to the use of another person’s image is not required where the reproduction is justified by the public office held, by the requirements of justice or policing, or by scientific, educational or cultural purposes.
The above-mentioned exceptions to the requirement of consent do not, however, apply where the use of another person’s image is prejudicial to the honour, reputation and dignity of the person depicted.
The existence of such prejudice therefore makes the use of the image unlawful even where it might, in theory, fall within the scope of the exceptions described above.
(Fabrizia Serpieri)
